This year is one where the public is signaling that it wants a big change. Both Trump and Sanders were the choices of people disgusted at the two-party duopoly's ability to prevent meaningful change, and allow the middle class to sink into poverty. The GOP had no choice, except to accept Trump as its nominee. And the Democratic establishment found a way to gyp Sanders of the votes he needed to win the nomination. As a result, we have the two least favorite candidates being in a position to be elected president.
Many Democrats are now saying that a vote for Johnson is a vote for Trump. This may be true, but only in the states where it's a toss up between Hillary and Trump. In states such as New York, there there are 3 Democratic party voters for every 2 from the GOP. It is safe for me to vote for the Libertarian choice, since I see no risk that Trump can win in New York.
I am under no illusions that the Libertarians can win. Johnson's total ignorance of world affairs shows him to be unqualified for the position of president. His Vice Presidential nominee is better qualified than he is, as Weld knows much more about the world outside the 50 states. Sadly, the Libertarians have way too many purists, and do not know how to compromise in order to gain power.
Yet, I see signs of hope for the long term. For the first time ever, I've seen a campaign sign for the Libertarian candidates posted near my house. They are slowly starting to get traction - after many years of wandering in the wilderness. People are seeing the Libertarians as a party they can support, if only as a protest against the two-party power duopoly.
Don't be surprised that some time in the next 20 years that the Libertarians become a major power in their own right. The Democrats have not been developing enough good leaders at the state level, and have ceded control of many states to the GOP. The GOP has taken ever more extreme positions, and no longer represent mainstream America. Why did it take so long for Trump to repudiate David Duke? The answer is simple - they have courted white supremacists since Richard Nixon's day, and they don't know how to break the deal with this devil. Please note that most Republicans are not racist. They only made the mistake of absorbing this blighted voting bloc when the Democrats cast them off by LBJ's signing of civil rights legislation.
The Libertarians are closer to classic GOP values than the current GOP is. Small government is a hallmark of the Libertarian party. The GOP promotes an ever bigger government, in the form of our military and its civilian workforce. Contrast this with the Libertarians who want to pull back from international quagmires, and work on domestic problems. I, for one, am afraid that if the GOP gets in control of the elected branches of government, that they will repeat the mistakes of Bush #43, and pay for military growth with debt - destroying the futures of our children and grandchildren, as they will be the ones who have to pay for our mistakes.
My advice: If you live in a state which is virtually guaranteed to vote Democratic, vote for the Libertarians if you can't stand Trump of Hillary. If you are in a state that is virtually guaranteed to vote Republican, vote for Libertarians if you can't stand Trump or Hillary. But if you live in a state that's up for grabs, vote for the candidate who is least objectionable. It's a terrible year in which to cast a vote. But we have a real choice, even though many of us will be holding our noses as we make it.